86 JOURNAL OF PROCEEDINGS [Jan. 18,

Loker,	Dennis,	Collins,
Martin,	Purnell,	Gardner,
Beck,	Thomas, of Fred'k,	Marshall,
Kilbourn,	Bowlus,	Neill,
Wells,	Bitter,	Welty,
Owings,	White,	Murdock,
Duke,	Harris,	Sword,
Carroll,	Ady,	Seibert,
Cameron,	Baldwin, of Harf.,	Hilton,
Ship ley,	Streett,	Watkins,
Gatch,	Garey,	Wilson, of Alle.,
Choate,	Sanner,	Standish,
Turner,	Hamilton,	Myers;
Harrington,	Cooper,	Shower,
Woolford,	Morse,	Jordan,
Meekins,	Blake,	Winters,
Touchstone,	Webb,	Grouse,
Richards,	Wilson, of B. city,	Crawford,
Marbury,	Wiley,	Gordy— 62.

So the motion to reconsider was decided in the negative.

The Secretary of the Senate delivered the following mes-
sage :

BY THE SENATE,

January 18, 1870.
Gentlemen of the House of Delegates:

We have received your message proposing that the two
Houses of the General Assembly go into joint convention for
the purpose of electing a Treasurer and non-concur therein,
for the reason that according to the ruling of the Senate the
mesiage was received pending the taking of a second ballot.
By order,

AUGUSTUS GASSAWAY,

Secretary.
Which was read.

Mr. Marbury moved that the House do now proceed to
another ballot for State Treasurer.

The question being upon concurring in the motion,
Mr. Marbury demanded the previous question,

The question now being, "shall the previous question be
now put," it was concurred in.

The question then recurring upon the motion submitted by
Mr. Marbury,

It was decided in the affirmative.